The Market Montauk Harbor
463 West Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954(631) 238-5433
Categories
- Face Masks (Adults & Children)
- Fresh Homemade Foods
- Market Salads are back!
- Fresh Fruits
- Fresh Vegetables
- Dairy
- "Non-Dairy" Dairy
- Frozen Foods
- Meats
- Pre-Packaged Sliced & cured Meats
- Cheese
- Pre-Packaged Sliced Cheeses
- Bread/Tortillas
- Gluten-Free Breads/GF Tortillas
- Baking/Mixes/Sweeteners
- Pancake/Waffle Mixes/Syrup
- Fresh Pasta
- Pasta/Tomato Sauces
- Grains
- Beans
- Condiments
- Oils/Dressings/Marinades
- Grocery
- Seasonings
- Jelly’s/Spreads
- Nuts/Seeds/Dried Fruit
- Cereal
- Salsa/Hummus/Dips
- Crackers
- Chips/Snacks
- Cookies/Sweets/Candy
- Bars/Single Snacks
- Juice
- Coffee/Tea/Hot Choc
- Water/Coconut Water
- Soda/Seltzers/Mixers/Drinks
- Beer/Alcohol
- Tobacco
- Medicines
- Baby Products
- Self Care
- Beach/Pool/Games/Sunscreen
- Ice/Grill/Outdoor
- Paper Goods
- Household/Cleaning Products
- Pet Products
- Empty Category
Welcome!
Select a category on the left to start your order.
Face Masks (Adults & Children)
-
12.0012.00Sold Out
Adult Triangle Print Mask
2-ply with opening for your own filter and built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!12.00Sold Out -
14.0014.00
Adult Floral Print Mask
2-ply with opening for your own filter and built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!14.00 -
14.0014.00
Adult Fish Print Mask
2-ply with opening for your own filter and built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!14.00 -
10.0010.00
Children's "Hey Diddle Diddle" Face Mask
2-ply built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!10.00 -
10.0010.00
Children's Minnie Mouse Face Mask
2-ply and built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!10.00 -
10.0010.00
Children's Paw Patrol Face Mask
2-ply and built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!10.00 -
10.0010.00
Children's Trolls Face Mask
2-ply and built-in wire to fit the nose. Handmade locally!10.00
Fresh Homemade Foods
-
3.003.00
Freshly Baked Croissant
Baked in-house! can also pre-order any amount you'd like...just give us a call!3.00 -
8.958.95Sold Out
Organic Overnight Oats
Made with all organic ... Gluten-Free Old Fashioned Oats, almond milk, almond butter and chia seeds. Topped with almonds, hemp seeds, coconut and fresh blueberries!8.95Sold Out -
8.258.25Sold Out
Organic Yogurt w/Homemade Granola, Bananas, Blueberries & Strawberries
all organic, lowfat plain yogurt, gluten free market granola8.25Sold Out
-
12.0012.00Sold Out
Blue Duck Bakery Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Fresh baked! 6"12.00Sold Out -
12.0012.00Sold Out
Blue Duck Bakery Sweet & Sour Cherry Pie
Fresh baked! 6"12.00Sold Out -
12.0012.00Sold Out
Blue Duck Bakery Wild Blueberry Pie
Fresh Baked! 6"12.00Sold Out -
12.0012.00Sold Out
Blue Duck Bakery Fresh Apple Pie
Fresh Baked! 6"12.00Sold Out
Market Salads are back!
-
17.9517.95Sold Out
Market Fresh Yellowfin Tuna Salad
Fresh Tuna Always! By the lb17.95Sold Out -
12.9512.95Sold Out
Market Chicken Salad
all natural, antibiotic free chicken12.95Sold Out -
6.996.99
Market Red Potato Salad
Amazing family recipe! per lb.6.99 -
6.996.99Sold Out
Market Macaroni Salad
So Fresh & Good!! per lb.6.99Sold Out -
6.996.99Sold Out
Cole Slaw
per lb.6.99Sold Out
Fresh Fruits
-
6.996.99Sold Out
Organic Strawberries
Pint6.99Sold Out -
3.993.99Sold Out
Organic Blueberries
Organic, 6 oz3.99Sold Out -
5.595.59Sold Out
Organic Blueberries- Pint
11 oz5.59Sold Out -
6.596.59Sold Out
Organic Raspberries
6 oz6.59Sold Out -
4.894.89
Champagne Grapes
Organic, seedless, purple4.89 -
4.994.99
Red Seedless Grapes
Organic, by the approx 2 lb bag4.99 -
4.094.09
Green Seedless Grapes
Organic4.09 -
4.394.39
Pineapple
Organic,4.39 -
0.890.89Sold Out
Bananas
Organic, Sold by piece0.89Sold Out -
1.791.79
Peaches
Organic, by piece1.79 -
1.291.29
Red Plums
Organic, by piece1.29 -
0.990.99
Gala Apples
Organic, sold by piece0.99 -
4.294.29
Honeydew Melon
4.29 -
6.996.99
Mini Watermelon
Organic, seedless6.99 -
1.791.79Sold Out
Valencia Oranges
Organic, Sold by piece1.79Sold Out -
0.750.75
Lemons
Sold by piece0.75 -
0.750.75Sold Out
Limes
Sold by piece0.75Sold Out -
A2.992.99
Avocados, Organic
Sold by piece2.99 -
4.894.89Sold Out
Tomatoes on the Vine
Organic, sold in bunches of 44.89Sold Out -
S5.295.29
Sungold Cherry Tomatoes
Organic, Sweet & so good! 8 oz5.29 -
4.594.59
Cherry Tomatoes
Organic, pint4.59
Fresh Vegetables
-
O4.994.99
Organic Baby Spring Mix
5 oz bag4.99 -
6.996.99Sold Out
Organic Girl Baby Spring Mix, Large
10 oz6.99Sold Out -
5.995.99Sold Out
Organic Baby Spinach- Small
5 oz5.99Sold Out -
2.992.99Sold Out
Iceberg Lettuce
Sold by head2.99Sold Out -
4.994.99
Pea Shoots
Organic, Sold by pint4.99 -
1.591.59
Local Bi-Color Corn
Organic, sold by ear1.59 -
5.795.79
Green Beans
Organic, Sold by 12 oz bag5.79 -
7.997.99Sold Out
Asparagus
Organic, sold by lb7.99Sold Out -
1.091.09
Zucchini
Organic1.09 -
1.091.09
Yellow Squash
Organic1.09 -
6.996.99
Brussel Sprouts
Organic, Sold By 1 lb Bag6.99 -
5.295.29
Organic Broccoli
By the Bunch5.29 -
3.993.99
Romanesco Cauliflower
Organic, Sold by head3.99 -
3.993.99
Whole Baby Bella Mushrooms
Organic, 8oz container3.99 -
2.252.25Sold Out
Organic Local Cucumbers
Sold by piece2.25Sold Out -
4.894.89
Yellow Peppers
sold / 2 peppers per4.89 -
4.194.19
Green Peppers
Sold by lb...approx 2 peppers4.19 -
3.893.89
Red Peppers
Sold by lb... approx 2 peppers3.89 -
0.590.59Sold Out
Jalapeno Pepper
Single pepper0.59Sold Out -
2.992.99Sold Out
Carrots
Organic 2 lb bags2.99Sold Out -
2.992.99
Celery
Organic, Sold by bunch2.99 -
3.193.19
Fresh Basil
Organic, Locally grown, By the bunch3.19 -
3.993.99
Fresh Cilantro
By the bunch3.99 -
2.992.99
Fresh Dill
By the bunch2.99 -
3.793.79Sold Out
Fresh Mint
Sold by Bunch3.79Sold Out -
3.593.59
Green Cabbage
Sold by head3.59 -
3.293.29
Red Cabbage
Sold by Head3.29 -
1.191.19Sold Out
Garlic
Sold by head1.19Sold Out -
0.990.99
Ginger
By the piece0.99 -
0.990.99
Scallions
By the bunch0.99 -
0.690.69
Shallots
large, sold by piece0.69 -
1.591.59
Yellow Onions
Organic, Sold by piece1.59 -
0.990.99
Red Onions
Organic, Sold by piece0.99 -
4.494.49
Urban Roots Organic Gold Pee Wee Potatoes
24 oz bag4.49 -
1.691.69
Red Potatoes
Sold in 1 lb Bag1.69 -
1.391.39
Organic Russet Potatoes
sold by piece1.39
Dairy
-
3.993.99Sold Out
Tuscan Whole Milk
1/2 gallon3.99Sold Out -
3.993.99Sold Out
Tuscan 2% Milk
1/2 gallon3.99Sold Out -
2.892.89
Tuscan Whole Milk
Quart2.89 -
2.892.89
Tuscan 2% Milk
Quart2.89 -
3.093.09
Tuscan Half & Half
quart3.09 -
6.596.59
Natural by Nature Whole Milk
Organic, 1/2 gallon6.59 -
6.796.79Sold Out
Organic Valley 2% Milk
1/2 gallon6.79Sold Out -
6.896.89
Organic Valley Lowfat 1% Milk
1/2 gallon6.89 -
7.397.39
Stonyfield Organic 1% Lowfat Milk
1/2 gallon7.39 -
6.896.89
Organic Valley Fat Free Milk
1/2 gallon6.89 -
5.595.59
Organic Valley Half & Half
Pint5.59 -
3.193.19
Organic Valley Heavy Whipping Cream
1/2 pint3.19 -
3.993.99
Cool Whip
8 oz3.99 -
4.994.99Sold Out
Natural by Nature Whipped Cream
Conventional, 7 oz4.99Sold Out -
2.992.99
Extra Large Eggs
1 dozen2.99 -
5.895.89
Organic Brown Eggs
1 dozen5.89 -
3.793.79Sold Out
Breakstone Salted Butter
2 sticks3.79Sold Out -
3.793.79Sold Out
Breakstone Unsalted Butter
2 sticks3.79Sold Out -
10.4910.49
Westby Sweet Cream Butter
Lightly Salted, 4 quarters, Organic10.49 -
10.9510.95
Organic Valley Unsalted Butter
10.95 -
4.594.59Sold Out
Philadelphia Cream Cheese
8 oz4.59Sold Out -
4.194.19
Organic Valley Cream Cheese
Organic, 8 oz tub4.19 -
3.893.89Sold Out
Byrne Dairy Sour Cream
16 oz3.89Sold Out -
4.994.99
Organic Valley Sour Cream
Full Fat, 16 oz4.99 -
5.795.79
Stonyfield Plain Lowfat Yogurt
Organic, 32 oz tub5.79 -
5.795.79
Stonyfield Vanilla Whole Milk Yogurt
Organic, probiotics, 32 oz tub5.79 -
6.296.29
Stonyfield Farms Organic Kid's Yogurt Cups
3 Strawberry banana, 3 strawberry, 4 oz each6.29 -
1.891.89
Chobani Strawberry Yogurt
Single serving cup, 5.3 oz1.89 -
1.891.89
Chobani Black Cherry
Single serving cup, 5.3 oz1.89 -
1.891.89
Chobani Peach Greek Yogurt
Single Serving cup, 5.3 oz1.89 -
1.891.89Sold Out
Chobani Blueberry Greek Yogurt
Single serving cup, 5.3 oz1.89Sold Out -
5.295.29
Fage 0% Milkfat Greek Yogurt
17.6 oz5.29
"Non-Dairy" Dairy
-
2.392.39Sold Out
Dahlicious Plain Almond Yogurt
India Style,100% plant-based & dairy free, 5.3 oz (single serving)2.39Sold Out -
2.492.49
Forager Cashew-milk Blueberry Yogurt
Vegan, organic, 5.3 oz single serving2.49 -
2.492.49
Forager Cashew-milk Cherry Yogurt
Vegan, Organic, 5.3 oz single serving2.49 -
2.492.49
Forager Cashew-milk Strawberry Yogurt
Vegan, Organic, 5.3 oz single serving2.49 -
7.997.99
Miyoko's Vegan Butter
Organic, 8 oz, We love this! Best Dairy Free Butter7.99 -
5.995.99
Daiya Classic Blend Shreds
Dairy/gluten/soy Free, cheddar & mozzarella style blend, 8 oz5.99 -
7.997.99Sold Out
Three Trees Original Almondmilk
Organic7.99Sold Out -
5.195.19
Pacific Foods Cashew Beverage
Organic, unsweetened, 32 oz5.19 -
4.294.29
Pacific Foods Almond Milk
Organic and unsweetened4.29 -
3.993.99Sold Out
RISE Brewing Co Oat Milk
Organic, cold brewed, vegan 32 oz3.99Sold Out -
7.097.09
Miyoko's Vegan Cheddar Slices
8 oz7.09 -
7.497.49Sold Out
Treeline Herb-Garlic Treenut Cheese
Vegan, GF, cheese spread, delicious with crackers, 6 oz7.49Sold Out
Frozen Foods
-
10.9910.99
Roberta's Margherita Pizza
3 min to cook and so good!10.99 -
11.9911.99
Roberta's Frozen Pizza, Baby Sinclair
1 pizza, wood fired, our favorite!11.99 -
14.4914.49
American Flatbread Tomato Sauce & 3 Cheese Pizza
Handmade, Wood-Fired, Thin & Crispy Pizza14.49 -
11.6911.69Sold Out
Against the Grain 3 Cheese Pizza
10 “ grain free/gf11.69Sold Out -
11.1911.19
Amy's Vegan Margherita Pizza
Organic, 3 servings11.19 -
7.697.69
Beyond Burger
Beef free, 2 per pack7.69 -
8.598.59
Applegate Homestyle Breaded Chicken Tenders
Antibiotic free, 8 oz8.59 -
8.598.59
Applegate Chicken Nuggets
Antibiotic free, 8 oz8.59 -
8.598.59Sold Out
Applegate Gluten-Free Chicken Nuggets
8 oz8.59Sold Out -
4.794.79
Cascadian Farm Crinkle French Fries
4.79 -
6.396.39
Alexia Sweet Potato Fries
Organic, 15 oz6.39 -
4.594.59
Cascadian Spud Puppies
Organic, 16 oz4.59 -
4.794.79
Cascadian Farm Hash Browns
16 oz4.79 -
8.098.09
Applegate Breakfast Sausage, Chicken Maple
10 fully cooked sausages, 7 oz8.09 -
5.895.89
Earth's Best Mini French Toast Bites
Organic, 8 oz5.89 -
4.094.09
Van's Original Waffles
Organic4.09 -
4.094.09
Nature's Path Gluten-Free Homestyle Waffles
Organic, 7.4 oz4.09 -
5.195.19
Earthbound Farm Riced Cauliflower
Organic, 10 oz5.19 -
3.993.99
Cascadian Frozen Edamame, Shelled
Organic, 10 0z3.99 -
4.594.59
Cascadian Riced Cauliflower Stir Fry
Organic, With stir fry vegetables (mushrooms, broccoli, peppers), 12 oz4.59 -
6.996.99
Woodstock Dark Sweet Cherries
Organic, 10 oz6.99 -
13.9913.99
Woodstock Wild Blueberries
Organic, 28 oz, frozen13.99 -
5.995.99
Cascadian Frozen Strawberries
Organic, 10 oz5.99 -
3.993.99Sold Out
Foodstirs Double Chocolate Mini Donuts
3 oz3.99Sold Out -
12.9912.99
Goodpop Organic Freezer Pops
Variety Pack- concord grape, strawberry limeade, fruit punch12.99 -
6.296.29Sold Out
Haagen Dazs Vanilla
1 pint6.29Sold Out -
6.296.29
Haagen Dazs Chocolate
Pint6.29 -
6.296.29
Haagen Dazs Strawberry
Pint6.29 -
6.996.99
Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia
Cherry ice cream with cherries & fudge flakes, 1 pint6.99 -
6.996.99
Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream with gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough, 1 pint6.99 -
6.996.99
Alden's Vanilla Creme Ice Cream
Organic, 14 oz6.99 -
6.996.99
Alden's Double Dark Chocolate Ice Cream
Organic, 14 oz6.99 -
6.996.99
Alden's Organic Cookie Dough Fudge Ice Cream
Pint, 14 oz6.99 -
6.996.99
Alden's Cherry Chip Ice Cream
Organic, 14 oz6.99 -
6.996.99
Alden's Organic Moose Tracks Ice Cream
1 Pint6.99 -
6.996.99
Alden's Organic Dairy Free Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream
Vegan, 1 pint6.99 -
8.898.89
Alden's Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich
6 sandwiches8.89 -
6.296.29
Alden's Organic Dairy Free Ice Cream Round Sandwich
Vanilla, 4 count6.29 -
6.996.99Sold Out
Coconut Bliss Vanilla Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
Organic/gluten free/vegan ice cream, 1 sandwich, 5.25 oz6.99Sold Out -
7.997.99
Nada Moo Vanilla Ice Cream
Made with Organic Coconut Milk, Dairy-Free, 1 pint7.99 -
7.997.99
Nada Moo Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream
Made with Organic Coconut Milk, Dairy-Free, 1 pint7.99 -
7.597.59Sold Out
Nada Moo Lotta Mint Chip Ice Cream
Dairy Free, made with coconut milk, 1 pint7.59Sold Out -
1.991.99
Marino's Cherry Italian Ice
Single serving, 6 oz1.99 -
1.991.99
Marino's Rainbow Italian Ice
Single Serving, 6 oz1.99
Meats
-
9.999.99Sold Out
Farmer Focus Chicken Breast
Organic, Boneless, skinless, 1.3 lbs9.99Sold Out -
8.998.99
Dakota Ground Beef
Organic Grass-Fed, 16 oz8.99 -
16.5916.59Sold Out
Dakota Beef Strip Steak
Organic, Grass-fed, 10 oz16.59Sold Out -
15.9915.99Sold Out
Dakota Beef Ribeye Steak
Organic Grass-fed, 10 oz15.99Sold Out -
7.697.69
Applegate Organic Beef Hot Dog
10 oz7.69 -
7.597.59
Organic Valley Turkey Hot Dogs
6 count7.59 -
6.996.99
Boars Head Skinless Beef Frankfurters
12.5 oz6.99 -
8.998.99
Boars Head Beef Frankfurters Natural Casing
uncured, 14 oz8.99 -
6.996.99Sold Out
Boars Head Bratwurst
1 lb6.99Sold Out
Pre-Packaged Sliced & cured Meats
-
7.997.99
Boars Head Sliced Bacon
Naturally Smoked, 1 lb7.99 -
9.899.89
Applegate Organic Sunday Bacon
Hickory smoked, uncured, 8 oz9.89 -
6.996.99
Garrett Valley Farms Turkey Bacon
Organic, Uncured, 8 oz6.99 -
7.197.19
Bellentani Black Pepper Coated Salami
Perfect to pair with one of our delicious cheeses! 7 oz7.19 -
7.097.09
Applegate Uncured Sliced Black Forest Ham
No antibiotics! 7 oz7.09 -
9.299.29Sold Out
Applegate Sliced Turkey
Organic, 6 oz9.29Sold Out -
7.997.99Sold Out
Boars Head Oven Roasted Turkey Slices
8 oz7.99Sold Out -
6.996.99Sold Out
Boars Head Cooked Uncured Ham Slices
8 oz6.99Sold Out -
5.995.99
Boars Head Bologna
6 oz5.99
Cheese
-
F9.959.95
Fresh Mozzarella
1 lb ball9.95 -
6.296.29
Lioni Ciliegine Fresh Mozzarella Balls
8 oz6.29 -
7.397.39
Polly-O Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheese
1 lb block7.39 -
4.594.59Sold Out
Koilos Greek Feta
Single block, 7 oz4.59Sold Out -
6.596.59
Castello Creamy Havarti
8 oz6.59 -
4.994.99
Tours de Paris Brie Wedge
Perfect to pair with our roasted garlic & herb crackers! 7 oz4.99 -
3.993.99
Belletoile Garlic & Herbs Cheese Spread
4.4 oz3.99 -
6.096.09
Kerrygold Dubliner Cheese
Our favorite! A sweet & nutty cheese, 7 oz6.09 -
6.696.69
Rumiano Organic Sharp Cheddar
8 oz6.69 -
5.395.39
Apple Smoked Gouda Round
8 oz5.39 -
4.894.89
Castello Traditional Blue Cheese Wedge
4.4 oz4.89
-
4.994.99
Sartori Parmesan Cheese Wedge
6 oz4.99 -
6.496.49
Organic Valley Shredded Parmesan
6.49 -
5.895.89
Sartori Basil & Olive Oil Asiago
International Award winning cheese5.89 -
5.795.79
Sartori Raspberry Ale Bellavitano
Best of Class World Championship Cheese Contest5.79
Pre-Packaged Sliced Cheeses
-
6.996.99Sold Out
Boars Head Sliced American Cheese
8 oz6.99Sold Out -
6.996.99
Boars Head Sliced Muenster Cheese
8 oz6.99 -
6.996.99Sold Out
Boars Head Sliced Provolone
Low Sodium, 8 oz6.99Sold Out -
7.997.99Sold Out
Boars Head Sliced Gold Label Swiss
7 oz7.99Sold Out -
O6.096.09
Organic Valley Muenster Sliced
Organic, 6 oz6.09 -
6.996.99
Organic Valley American (Unprocessed) Cheese
8 oz6.99 -
6.696.69
Applegate Naturals Emmentaler Swiss Cheese
No added hormones, 8 oz6.69 -
O5.595.59
Organic Valley Stringles, Mozzarella
6 oz5.59
Bread/Tortillas
-
2.992.99
Joseph's Pita Bread
Flax, Oat Bran & Whole Wheat, 6 count2.99 -
2.992.99
Joseph's Mini Pita Bread
8 pitas2.99 -
2.992.99
Joseph's Lavash Bread
4 flatbreads2.99 -
4.494.49
Heidelberg Cracked Wheat
4.49 -
4.494.49Sold Out
Heidelberg Multigrain
4.49Sold Out -
4.494.49
Heidelberg French Peasant Loaf
All natural!4.49 -
4.494.49
Heidelberg Jewish Rye
A favorite!4.49 -
3.593.59
Kasanof's Marble Rye
3.59 -
3.593.59
Kasanof's Seeded Rye
3.59 -
3.593.59
Kasanof's No Seeds Rye
3.59 -
3.593.59
Kasanof's Russian Pumpernickel Rye
16 oz3.59 -
4.794.79Sold Out
Vermont Bread Soft White
4.79Sold Out -
4.994.99Sold Out
Vermont Bread Organic Soft White
4.99Sold Out -
4.794.79Sold Out
Vermont Bread Soft Whole Wheat
4.79Sold Out -
4.994.99
Vermont Bread Organic Soft Wheat
4.99 -
4.994.99
Vermont Bread Organic Soft Multigrain
4.99 -
4.794.79
Vermont Bread Soft 10 Grain
4.79 -
4.794.79
Vermont Bread Potato Bread
4.79 -
4.294.29
Vermont Bread Cinnamon Raisin
Wheat, Breakfast Bread, 20 oz4.29 -
V3.893.89
Vermont Bread Potato Sandwich Rolls
6 count3.89 -
V3.893.89Sold Out
Vermont Bread White Sandwich Rolls
6 count3.89Sold Out -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Golden White English Muffins
2.99 -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Whole Wheat English Muffins
2.99 -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Multigrain English Muffins
6 muffins2.99 -
2.992.99Sold Out
Vermont Bread Potato English Muffins
6 muffins2.99Sold Out -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Potato Hamburger Buns
8 buns2.99 -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Potato Hot Dog Buns
8 buns2.99 -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Whole Wheat Hamburger Buns
8 buns2.99 -
2.992.99
Vermont Bread Whole Wheat Hot Dog Buns
8 buns2.99