Gumby's Pizza - Madison Wisconsin
2825 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705(608) 298-7550
Categories
Welcome!
Select a category on the left to start your order.
💰 Super Value Menu 💰
🔥 🔥 Red Hot Deals 🔥🔥
-
15.99 - 26.9915.99 - 26.99
🚀🚀🚀Online Only 3-Topping Pizza or Pokey Stix
15.99 - 26.99 -
19.99 - 54.9919.99 - 54.99
Couch Potato Special
EXTRA-Large 1-Topping Pizza or an EXTRA-Large Pokey Stix or 10 Pepperoni Rolls19.99 - 54.99 -
32.99 - 43.9932.99 - 43.99
Triple Trouble
1-Topping Pizza + World Famous Pokey Stix + Buffalo Wings32.99 - 43.99 -
27.99 - 32.9927.99 - 32.99
5-Topper Bonanza
Pizza with any 5 Toppings27.99 - 32.99 -
14.99 - 17.9914.99 - 17.99
1-Topping Pizza or Pokey Stix (Pick Up Only)
14.99 - 17.99
♨️Chicken Wing Baskets🍟
Specialty Pizzas
Available Base Sauce Choices: BBQ Sauce, Traditional Pizza Sauce.
-
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Stoner Pie
Mozzarella Stix, Pepperoni, French Fries, Bacon And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Pepperoni Powerhouse Pizza
Double Pepperoni And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Meat Locker Pizza
Meatballs, Sausage, Pepperoni, Extra Cheese Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" Xl, 20" Massive, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Maui Wowi Pizza
Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Pineapple, Mushrooms, BBQ Sauce And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Heart Attack Pizza
Double Pepperoni, Double Bacon And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Green and White Pizza
Ricotta Cheese, Spinach And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Galore Pizza
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Onions, Mushrooms, Peppers, Black Olives And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
22.99 - 26.9922.99 - 26.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chicken Tenders, Bacon, Ranch And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.22.99 - 26.99 -
23.99 - 27.9923.99 - 27.99
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Grilled Chicken, Spinach, Tomatoes, Alfredo Sauce And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.23.99 - 27.99 -
23.99 - 27.9923.99 - 27.99
Butcher Shop Pizza
Pepperoni, Ham, Meatballs, Sausage And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.23.99 - 27.99 -
23.99 - 27.9923.99 - 27.99
Blockhead Pizza
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Bacon, Ham And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.23.99 - 27.99 -
23.99 - 27.9923.99 - 27.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ Sauce, Grilled Chicken And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.23.99 - 27.99 -
23.99 - 27.9923.99 - 27.99
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Bacon, Beef, Cheddar Cheese And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.23.99 - 27.99 -
23.99 - 27.9923.99 - 27.99
Aloha Chicken Pizza
BBQ Sauce, Chicken Tenders, Pineapple And Extra Cheese. Choice Of 10" Small, 14" Large, 16" X-Large, 20" Massive, Small, Or 12" Medium.23.99 - 27.99
Specialty Calzones
-
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Bacon Cheeseburger Calzone
Bacon, Beef, Cheddar, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
BBQ Chicken Calzone
BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Onions, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Blockhead Calzone
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Bacon, Ham, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Chicken Alfredo Calzone
Grilled Chicken, Spinach, Tomato, Alfredo Sauce.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Calzone
Chicken Tenders, Bacon, Ranch, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Galore Calzone
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Onion, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Black Olives, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Green & White Calzone
Ricotta, Spinach, Broccoli, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Heart Attack Calzone
Double Pepperoni, Double Bacon, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Maui Wowi Calzone
Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Pineapple, Mushrooms, BBQ Sauce, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Pepperoni Powerhouse Calzone
Triple Pepperoni, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Stoner Pie Calzone
Pepperoni, Bacon, French Fries, Mozzarella Stix.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Aloha Chicken Calzone
BBQ Sauce, Chicken Tenders, Pineapple, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Butcher Shop Calzone
Pepperoni, Ham, Meatballs, Sausage, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Meat Locker Calzone
Meatballs, Pepperoni, Sausage, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99
Specialty Strombolis
-
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Aloha Chicken Stromboli
BBQ Sauce, Chicken Tenders, Pineapple, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Bacon Cheeseburger Stromboli
Bacon, Beef, Cheddar and X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Stoner Pie Stromboli
Mozzarella Stix, Pepperoni, French Fries, Bacon, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Blockhead Stromboli
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Bacon, Ham and X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Cluck You!! Stromboli
Chicken Tenders, Grilled Chicken, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
BBQ Chicken Stromboli
BBQ Sauce, Chicken, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Butcher Shop Stromboli
Pepperoni, Ham, Meatballs, Sausage, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Chicken Alfredo Stromboli
Grilled Chicken, Spinach, Tomato, Alfredo Sauce.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Galore Stromboli
Pepperoni, Sausage, Beef, Onion, Mushrooms, Peppers, Black Olives, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Heart Attack Stromboli
Double Pepperoni, Double Bacon, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Maui Wowi Stromboli
Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Pineapple, Mushrooms, BBQ Sauce, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Pepperoni Powerhouse Stromboli
Double Pepperoni, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99 -
19.99 - 23.9919.99 - 23.99
Meat Locker Stromboli
Meatballs, Pepperoni, Sausage, X-Cheese.19.99 - 23.99
Calzones and Stromboli
🥪Hot & Cold Signature Subs
-
12.9912.99Sold Out
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch
Chicken Tenders, Cheddar, Bacon, Ranch Dressing. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.12.99Sold Out
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Tenders, Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99
Phat Philly Cheesesteak
Steak, Mushroom, Onions, Sweet Peppers, Provolone Cheese. Choice Of 8" Sub Combo Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99
-
8.99 - 25.998.99 - 25.99
Chicken Philly Cheesesteak
Grilled Chicken, Mushroom, Onion, Peppers Choice Of 8" Sub Or 12" Sub.8.99 - 25.99
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Backyard BBQ
Chicken Tenders, Steak, Onions, Sweet Peppers, Provolone Cheese, BBQ Sauce. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99
Meatball
Meatballs, Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Crazy Italian
Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Oil, Vinegar, Sweet Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99Sold Out
French Dip(Boars Head)
Roast Beef And Provolone Cheese Served With Au Jus Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99Sold Out -
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Gumby's Cuban(Boars Head)
Turkey, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Pickles And Mustard - All Served Hot! Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Boars Head Ace Of Clubs
Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
10.99 - 24.9910.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Gator Bait(Boars Head)
Roast Beef, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.10.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
8.99 - 24.998.99 - 24.99Sold Out
King Of Clubs(Boars Head)
Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.8.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
8.99 - 22.998.99 - 22.99Sold Out
Deli Sandwiches
Served on a round bun with a bag of potato chips. All sandwiches come with cheese, lettuce, and tomato.8.99 - 22.99Sold Out -
10.99 - 24.9910.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Wild Turkey(Boars Head)
Turkey, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.10.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
10.99 - 25.9910.99 - 25.99Sold Out
Dirty Birdy(Boars Head)
Turkey, Ham, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.10.99 - 25.99Sold Out
-
10.99 - 24.9910.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Tricky Niki(Boars Head)
Roast Beef, Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.10.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
10.99 - 24.9910.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Tuna Melt
Tuna Salad, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.10.99 - 24.99Sold Out
-
10.99 - 24.9910.99 - 24.99Sold Out
Tuna
Tuna Salad, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Choice Of 8" Sub, 12" Sub, 8" Sub Combo, Or 12" Sub Combo.10.99 - 24.99Sold Out
🥗🥗Giant Salads🥗🥗
Sides
🥤🥤Beverages🥤🥤
🏃🏃♀️ Pick-Up Deals🏃🏃♀️
-
15.99 - 29.9915.99 - 29.99
🚀🚀🚀Online Only 3-Topping Pizza or Pokey Stix (Pick Up Only)
15.99 - 29.99 -
13.9913.99
🏃 Dash Deals
Pick-Up Only(order will void if ordered on delivery)13.99 -
15.99 - 29.9915.99 - 29.99
🏃2 Topping Pizza Or Pokey Stix
Pick-Up Only(order will void if ordered on delivery)15.99 - 29.99
Dynamic Category
Your Order
This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.
Your order is empty.
Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
Info
Online Ordering Powered by:
Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
Sorry, we're closed right now.
Sign In
Forgot Your Password?
Please enter your e-mail address, and we'll send you a link to reset your password.
Item Added
Your selection has been added to your order.
Make Your Order Even Better!
Item Added
Your selection has been added to your order.
Continue Ordering
Have a Coupon?
If you have a coupon code, enter it and click Apply Coupon.
Complete Your Order
Complete Your Coupon
You've earned a free item! Select the item you want below.
Info
Your Order
This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.
Your order is empty.
Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
We're On It!
Your items have been sent and we're working on it! Want to order more? Go for it!