Go to main content
The Pie

The Pie

216 Main Street, PORT JEFF STA, NY 11777
(631) 331-4646
Already Registered? Sign In
Back
The Pie

Categories

  • Empty Category

Welcome!

Select a category on the left to start your order.

Specials

  • 16.95
    16.95

    Risotto Rice Balls

    16.95
    Stuffed with fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.25
    16.25

    Mac & cheese bites

    16.25
    Topped with Cajun cheese sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 17.25
    17.25

    Coal Fired Brussel Sprouts

    17.25
    Apples, walnuts & bacon
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 28.95
    28.95

    Coal Fired Organic Chicken

    28.95
    Fall vegetables, sweet potatoes
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 27.50
    27.50

    Chicken Rollatini

    27.50
    Prosciutto, mozzarella , Marsala wine
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.99
    16.99

    Avocado Salad

    16.99
    Arugula, goat cheese, walnuts, cherry tomatoes , lemon & EVOO
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.99
    16.99

    Pear and Gouda

    16.99
    Mixed greens, walnuts, balsamic
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 28.95
    28.95

    Chicken Milanese

    28.95
    arugula, cherry tomatoes, lemon, and olive oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.95
    16.95

    Stuffed Portabello

    16.95
    Served with Goat Cheese and Roasted Red Peppers
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95
    15.95

    Artichoke Heart Oreganata

    15.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Great Beginnings

  • 15.75
    15.75

    Risotto Rice Balls

    15.75
    stuffed with fresh mozzerella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.95
    16.95

    Mac & Cheese bites

    16.95
    topped with cajun cheese sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.50
    16.50

    Meatball sliders

    16.50
    ricotta, mozzerella on a garlic knot
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    Mozzarella Sticks

    13.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 12.95
    12.95

    Fried Ravioli

    12.95
    Marinara dipping sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    Zucchini Fritte

    13.95
    Crisp zucchini served with marinara and garlic aioli
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.75
    19.75

    Sampler Platter

    19.75
    Mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, fried zucchini
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.25
    11.25

    Buffalo Wings (6)

    11.25
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.50
    8.50

    Coal Fired Garlic Bread

    8.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Coal Fired Garlic Bread w/ Mozzarella

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Garlic Knots (3)

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    House Meatballs (3)

    13.95
    Topped with ricotta and mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.50
    16.50

    Calamari Fritte

    16.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.50
    15.50

    Baked Clams

    15.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.50
    14.50

    Mozzarella en Carrozza

    14.50
    Fresh mozzarella lightly breaded
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.50
    15.50

    Clams Oreganato

    15.50
    Littleneck clams, garlic, basil, toasted oreganato and breadcrumbs
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 17.50
    17.50

    Calamari Garlic Aioli

    17.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.50
    18.50

    Calamari Arabiatta

    18.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.75
    13.75

    Fried Artichokes

    13.75
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.75
    16.75

    Coal Fired Brussel Sprouts

    16.75
    apples, walnuts, bacon
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95
    19.95

    Buffalo Wings (12)

    19.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95
    19.95

    House Meatballs (5)

    19.95
    topped with ricotta and mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.95
    16.95

    Stuffed Portabello

    16.95
    Served with Goat Cheese and Roasted Red Peppers
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Salads

  • 9.95 - 41.50
    9.95 - 41.50

    House Salad

    9.95 - 41.50
    Tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrots, croutons, mushrooms, candied walnuts, and red wine vinaigrette
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 12.99
    12.99

    Classic Caesar

    12.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.99 - 28.99
    16.99 - 28.99

    Flat Bread Focaccia

    16.99 - 28.99
    Seasoned coal fired crust topped with our house salad
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.99
    13.99

    Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Plate

    13.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.99
    16.99

    Gorgonzola

    16.99
    Mixed greens, red onion, cucumber, roasted pepper, candied walnuts, crumbled gorgonzola, balsamic vinaigrette
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.99
    16.99

    Grilled Vegetable

    16.99
    Portobello mushrooms, zucchini, eggplant, roasted pepper over mixed greens and balsamic reduction
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.99
    16.99

    Caramelized Pear Salad

    16.99
    Caramelized pears, tomatoes, red onion, candied walnuts, gorgonzola cheese over mixed greens with raspberry vinaigrette
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.75
    16.75

    Avocado Salad

    16.75
    Arugula, cherry tomatoes, candied walnuts, goat cheese, lemon and olive oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.75
    16.75
    Sold Out

    Pear and Gouda

    16.75
    Sold Out
    Mixed greens, walnuts, balsamic
    Add Special Instructions

Soups

  • 10.50
    10.50

    Homemade Stracciatella

    10.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.50
    10.50

    Tortellini en Brodo

    10.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.50
    10.50

    Minestrone

    10.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.50
    10.50

    Tomato Blue Cheese

    10.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.50
    10.50

    Potato & Leek

    10.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.50
    10.50
    Sold Out

    Butternut Squash

    10.50
    Sold Out
    Add Special Instructions

Coal Fired Pizza

  • 13.50 - 23.50
    13.50 - 23.50

    Classic Margherita Pie

    13.50 - 23.50
    Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino romano, olive oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 31.75
    19.50 - 31.75

    Di Parma

    19.50 - 31.75
    Sliced parma prosciutto, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.50 - 26.99
    16.50 - 26.99

    Blanco

    16.50 - 26.99
    Ricotta, fresh mozzarella, olive oil, fresh basil and romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95 - 32.75
    19.95 - 32.75

    Rustica

    19.95 - 32.75
    Broccoli rabe, sausage, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, parmigiano, olive oil (with or without our tomato sauce) and garlic
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.50 - 33.75
    20.50 - 33.75

    Shrimp

    20.50 - 33.75
    Fresh shrimp or littleneck clams prepared with fresh garlic, white wine, fresh mozzarella and toasted breadcrumbs oreganato
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 31.75
    19.50 - 31.75

    Verde

    19.50 - 31.75
    Chicken, pesto, ricotta and fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 31.75
    19.50 - 31.75

    Barbeque Style

    19.50 - 31.75
    Chicken, bbq sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese & caramelized onions
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 32.75
    19.50 - 32.75

    Melanzana Pie

    19.50 - 32.75
    Eggplant, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, tomato sauce
    and fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.50 - 34.25
    20.50 - 34.25

    Supreme Pie

    20.50 - 34.25
    Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, peppers, onions, black olives, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 31.25
    19.50 - 31.25

    Vegetable Pie

    19.50 - 31.25
    Asparagus, portobello mushrooms, eggplant, kalamata olives, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, olive oil and shaved parmigiano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 31.75
    19.50 - 31.75

    Buffalo Pie

    19.50 - 31.75
    Spicy chicken, blue cheese & fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50 - 31.25
    19.50 - 31.25

    Baby Bella

    19.50 - 31.25
    Wild mushrooms, spinach, truffle oil, ricotta and fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.50 - 33.75
    20.50 - 33.75

    Clam Pie

    20.50 - 33.75
    Fresh shrimp or littleneck clams prepared with fresh garlic, white wine, fresh mozzarella and toasted breadcrumbs oreganato
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95 - 32.75
    19.95 - 32.75

    Chicken Ranch

    19.95 - 32.75
    cheddar, mozzarella and bacon
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Coal Fired Calzones

  • 15.99
    15.99

    The Original

    15.99
    Seasoned ricotta, mozzarella and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 22.50
    22.50

    Broccoli Rabe & Spicy Sausage

    22.50
    Ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli rabe, hot Italian sausage and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.25
    19.25

    Meat Calzone

    19.25
    Meat sauce, ricotta, fresh mozzarella and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 22.99
    22.99

    Vegetable Calzone

    22.99
    Portobello mushrooms, eggplant, spinach, ricotta, fresh mozzarella and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Pasta

  • 21.99
    21.99

    Penne Alla Vodka

    21.99
    Vodka tomato cream sauce sautéed with prosciutto, onions and basil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 22.99
    22.99

    Gnocchi Bolognese

    22.99
    Meat sauce topped with ricotta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.50
    20.50

    Spaghetti & Meatballs

    20.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.99
    23.99

    Chicken & Broccoli

    23.99
    Chicken, broccoli, garlic, oil, fresh tomato and rigatoni pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 22.50
    22.50

    Capellini Primavera

    22.50
    Asparagus, shiitake mushrooms, sundried tomato, fresh zucchini, fresh garlic and oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.99
    23.99

    Linguini with Clam Sauce

    23.99
    Red or white
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.99
    23.99

    Rigatoni Rustica

    23.99
    Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, garlic & oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 26.99
    26.99

    Shrimp Cappellini

    26.99
    Arugula, tomatoes, roasted garlic, white wine
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 17.75
    17.75

    Ravioli

    17.75
    Cheese ravioli with tomato sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50
    19.50

    Baked Ravioli

    19.50
    Cheese ravioli with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 17.75 - 18.99
    17.75 - 18.99

    Baked Ziti

    17.75 - 18.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 22.50
    22.50

    Fettuccine Alfredo

    22.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95
    19.95

    Lasagna with Meat

    19.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Parmigiana

  • 13.50 - 25.25
    13.50 - 25.25

    Chicken

    13.50 - 25.25
    Dinner - served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.50 - 25.25
    13.50 - 25.25

    Meatball

    13.50 - 25.25
    Dinner - served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 12.50 - 23.99
    12.50 - 23.99

    Eggplant

    12.50 - 23.99
    Dinner - served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.50 - 25.25
    13.50 - 25.25

    Sausage & Peppers

    13.50 - 25.25
    Dinner - served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.50 - 27.25
    15.50 - 27.25

    Shrimp

    15.50 - 27.25
    Dinner - served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Main Plates

  • 28.95
    28.95

    Coal Fired Organic Chicken

    28.95
    sweet potatoes and fall vegetables.
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 24.50
    24.50

    Eggplant Rollatini

    24.50
    Ricotta, marinara, melted mozzarella. served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 27.50
    27.50

    Chicken Rollatini

    27.50
    stuffed w/ prosciutto, mozzarella, marsala wine sauce. served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 26.99
    26.99

    Chicken Francese

    26.99
    Lemon, butter, white wine sauce. served with Penne Pasta. served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 26.99
    26.99

    Chicken Marsala

    26.99
    Fresh mushrooms, brown marsala sauce. served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 26.99
    26.99

    Chicken Scarpariello

    26.99
    Sweet sausage, potatoes, cherry peppers, mushrooms
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 27.99
    27.99

    Chicken Sorrentino

    27.99
    Eggplant, prosciutto, mushroom, melted mozzarella. served with Penne Pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Sides

  • 13.25 - 15.25
    13.25 - 15.25

    Broccoli Rabe

    13.25 - 15.25
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Escarole & Beans

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.25
    10.25

    Broccoli

    10.25
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.25
    11.25

    Spinach

    11.25
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.25
    11.25

    Meatballs (3)

    11.25
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 5.99
    5.99

    Side of French Fries

    5.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 0.50
    0.50

    Side of Sauce

    0.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.25
    15.25

    Broccoli Rabe with sausage

    15.25
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Kids Menu

  • 11.50
    11.50

    Chicken Fingers & Fries

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Mozzarella Sticks

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Mac & Cheese

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Grilled Cheese & Fries

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Penne Vodka

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Florets

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Kids Pasta Bowl

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 3.75
    3.75

    (1) Meatball

    3.75
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Desserts

  • 10.50
    10.50

    Brownie Sundae

    10.50
    Ghirardelli chocolate brownie served with vanilla bean ice cream and whipped cream
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.95
    10.95

    Fried Oreo

    10.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.95
    9.95

    Cookie Dough Blast

    9.95
    Warm chocolate chip cookie with chocolate filling served with vanilla bean ice cream
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.95
    9.95

    Funnel Sticks

    9.95
    Sweet fried dough dusted with confectioners' sugar served with caramel dipping sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.95
    9.95

    Tartufo

    9.95
    Vanilla and chocolate ice cream with raspberry and nut center dipped ia a dark chocolate shell
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Sweetie Pie Sundae

    14.95
    Warm sweet dough topped with vanilla bean ice cream, caramel, chocolate syrup and whipped cream ( serves 2 or more)
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95
    15.95

    Nutella S'mores Pie

    15.95
    Warm sweet dough topped with roasted marshmallow, banana and graham crackers (serves 2 or more )
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.50
    8.50

    Mini Cannoli (3)

    8.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.50
    8.50

    NY Cheesecake

    8.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Tiramisu

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Beverages

  • 4.00
    4.00

    2 Liter Coke

    4.00
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.00
    4.00

    2 Liter Diet Coke

    4.00
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.00
    4.00

    2 Liter Sprite

    4.00
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.50
    4.50

    Boylan Black Cherry

    4.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.50
    4.50

    Boylan Creme

    4.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.50
    4.50

    Boylan Orange

    4.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.50
    4.50

    Boylan Ginger Ale

    4.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.50
    4.50

    Boylan Root Beer

    4.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.50
    2.50

    20oz Coke

    2.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.50
    2.50

    20oz Diet Coke

    2.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.50
    2.50

    20oz Sprite

    2.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

GIFT CARDS!

  • 25.00
    25.00

    $25 Gift Card for The Pie

    25.00
    Please enter information in the "Add Special Instructions" text box BELOW and provide the necessary information:


    GIFT CARD FOR (Name):

    FULL POSTAL ADDRESS:
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 50.00
    50.00

    $50 Gift Card for The Pie

    50.00
    Please enter information in the "Add Special Instructions" text box BELOW and provide the necessary information:


    GIFT CARD FOR (Name):

    FULL POSTAL ADDRESS:
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 50.00
    50.00

    $75 Gift Card for The Pie

    50.00
    Please enter information in the "Add Special Instructions" text box BELOW and provide the necessary information:


    GIFT CARD FOR (Name):

    FULL POSTAL ADDRESS:
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 100.00
    100.00

    $100 Gift Card for The Pie

    100.00
    Please enter information in the "Add Special Instructions" text box BELOW and provide the necessary information:


    GIFT CARD FOR (Name):

    FULL POSTAL ADDRESS:
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Dynamic Category

      Your Order

      This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.

      Your order is empty.

      {{combo.name}} Delete Combo {{comboPrice(combo)}}

      Already Sent

      Subtotal

      Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
      {{submitButtonText}}

      Info

      Already Registered? Sign In
      Online Ordering Powered by:
      Orders2me Online Ordering System for Restaurants
      Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
      {{submitButtonText}}

      Start Your Order

      Sorry, we're closed right now. When do you want to order?

      Order Type
      Order Time
      In-store Pickup orders are not available right now.
      We deliver, but delivery is not available right now.

      Already Registered?

      Invalid e-mail address or password.
      Forgot password?

      Sign In

      Invalid e-mail address or password.
      Forgot password?

      Forgot Your Password?

      Please enter your e-mail address, and we'll send you a link to reset your password.

      Please check your e-mail

      Item Added

      Your selection has been added to your order.
      Make Your Order Even Better!

      Item Added

      Your selection has been added to your order.
      Continue Ordering

      Have a Coupon?

      If you have a coupon code, enter it and click Apply Coupon.

      Complete Your Order

      Complete Your Coupon

      You've earned a free item! Select the item you want below.

      Info

      Your Order

      This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.

      Your order is empty.

      {{combo.name}} Delete Combo {{comboPrice(combo)}}

      Already Sent

      Subtotal

      Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
      {{submitButtonText}}

      We're On It!

      Your items have been sent and we're working on it! Want to order more? Go for it!