Go to main content
The Pie

The Pie

216 Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
(631) 331-4646
Already Registered? Sign In
Back
The Pie

Categories

  • Great Beginnings
  • Salads
  • Soups
  • Coal Fired Pizza
  • Coal Fired Calzones
  • Pasta
  • Parmigiana
  • Main Plates
  • Sides
  • Kids Menu
  • Desserts
  • Beverages
  • Catering Package
  • Empty Category

Welcome!

Select a category on the left to start your order.

Great Beginnings

  • 13.95
    13.95

    Risotto Rice Balls

    13.95
    stuffed with fresh mozzerella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    Mac & Cheese bites

    13.95
    topped with cajun cheese sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    Meatball sliders

    13.95
    ricotta, mozzerella on a garlic knot
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.95
    11.95

    Mozzarella Sticks

    11.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.95
    10.95

    Fried Ravioli

    10.95
    Marinara dipping sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.95
    11.95

    Zucchini Fritte

    11.95
    Crisp zucchini served with marinara and garlic aioli
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.95
    16.95

    Sampler Platter

    16.95
    Mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, fried zucchini
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50 - 16.50
    9.50 - 16.50

    Buffalo Wings

    9.50 - 16.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 6.50
    6.50

    Coal Fired Garlic Bread

    6.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Coal Fired Garlic Bread w/ Mozzarella

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.75
    2.75

    Garlic Knots (3)

    2.75
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.75 - 16.95
    10.75 - 16.95

    House Meatballs

    10.75 - 16.95
    Topped with ricotta and mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    Calamari Fritte

    13.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 12.50
    12.50

    Baked Clams

    12.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.95
    11.95

    Mozzarella en Carrozza

    11.95
    Fresh mozzarella lightly breaded
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Bruschetta Di Pomodoro

    11.50
    Plum tomato, red onion, basil, fresh mozzarella with garlic crostini
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.50
    13.50

    Clams Oreganato

    13.50
    Littleneck clams, garlic, basil, toasted oreganato and breadcrumbs
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Calamari Garlic Aioli

    14.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95
    15.95

    Calamari Arabiatta

    15.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 12.95
    12.95

    Fried Artichokes

    12.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95
    15.95

    Coal Fired Brussel Sprouts

    15.95
    apples, walnuts, bacon
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Mussels

    14.95
    Served with Red or white Sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Salads

  • 8.95 - 36.95
    8.95 - 36.95

    House Salad

    8.95 - 36.95
    Tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrots, croutons, mushrooms, candied walnuts, and red wine vinaigrette
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.95
    9.95

    Classic Caesar

    9.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95 - 24.95
    14.95 - 24.95

    Flat Bread Focaccia

    14.95 - 24.95
    Seasoned coal fired crust topped with our house salad
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50
    11.50

    Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Plate

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Gorgonzola

    14.95
    Mixed greens, red onion, cucumber, roasted pepper, candied walnuts, crumbled gorgonzola, balsamic vinaigrette
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Grilled Vegetable

    14.95
    Portobello mushrooms, zucchini, eggplant, roasted pepper over mixed greens and balsamic reduction
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Caramelized Pear Salad

    14.95
    Caramelized pears, tomatoes, red onion, candied walnuts, gorgonzola cheese over mixed greens with raspberry vinaigrette
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95
    15.95

    Avocado Salad

    15.95
    Arugula, cherry tomatoes, candied walnuts, goat cheese, lemon and olive oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95
    15.95
    Sold Out

    Watermelon and Feta

    15.95
    Sold Out
    Add Special Instructions
  • 15.95
    15.95

    Pear and Gouda

    15.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Soups

  • 5.95 - 8.95
    5.95 - 8.95

    Homemade Stracciatella

    5.95 - 8.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 5.95 - 8.95
    5.95 - 8.95

    Tortellini en Brodo

    5.95 - 8.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 5.95 - 8.95
    5.95 - 8.95

    Minestrone

    5.95 - 8.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 5.95 - 8.95
    5.95 - 8.95

    Tomato Blue Cheese

    5.95 - 8.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Coal Fired Pizza

  • 12.95 - 20.95
    12.95 - 20.95

    Classic Margherita Pie

    12.95 - 20.95
    Crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino romano, olive oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 26.95
    18.95 - 26.95

    Di Parma

    18.95 - 26.95
    Sliced parma prosciutto, kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 15.95 - 23.95
    15.95 - 23.95

    Blanco

    15.95 - 23.95
    Ricotta, fresh mozzarella, olive oil, fresh basil and romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 27.95
    18.95 - 27.95

    Rustica

    18.95 - 27.95
    Broccoli rabe, sausage, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, parmigiano, olive oil (with or without our tomato sauce) and garlic
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95 - 29.95
    19.95 - 29.95

    Shrimp

    19.95 - 29.95
    Fresh shrimp or littleneck clams prepared with fresh garlic, white wine, fresh mozzarella and toasted breadcrumbs oreganato
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 27.95
    18.95 - 27.95

    Verde

    18.95 - 27.95
    Chicken, pesto, ricotta and fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 27.95
    18.95 - 27.95

    Barbeque Style

    18.95 - 27.95
    Chicken, bbq sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese & caramelized onions
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 27.95
    18.95 - 27.95

    Melanzana Pie

    18.95 - 27.95
    Eggplant, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, tomato sauce
    and fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95 - 29.95
    19.95 - 29.95

    Supreme Pie

    19.95 - 29.95
    Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, peppers, onions, black olives, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 26.95
    18.95 - 26.95

    Vegetable Pie

    18.95 - 26.95
    Asparagus, portobello mushrooms, eggplant, kalamata olives, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, olive oil and shaved parmigiano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 26.95
    18.95 - 26.95

    Baby Bella

    18.95 - 26.95
    Wild mushrooms, spinach, truffle oil, ricotta and fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95 - 27.95
    18.95 - 27.95

    Buffalo Pie

    18.95 - 27.95
    Spicy chicken, blue cheese & fresh mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95 - 29.95
    19.95 - 29.95

    Clam Pie

    19.95 - 29.95
    Fresh shrimp or littleneck clams prepared with fresh garlic, white wine, fresh mozzarella and toasted breadcrumbs oreganato
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.96 - 28.95
    19.96 - 28.95

    Chicken Ranch

    19.96 - 28.95
    cheddar, mozzarella and bacon
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Coal Fired Calzones

  • 14.95
    14.95

    The Original

    14.95
    Seasoned ricotta, mozzarella and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.50
    19.50

    Broccoli Rabe & Spicy Sausage

    19.50
    Ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli rabe, hot Italian sausage and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.95
    16.95

    Meat Calzone

    16.95
    Meat sauce, ricotta, fresh mozzarella and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95
    19.95

    Vegetable Calzone

    19.95
    Portobello mushrooms, eggplant, spinach, ricotta, fresh mozzarella and pecorino romano
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Pasta

  • 18.95
    18.95

    Penne Alla Vodka

    18.95
    Vodka tomato cream sauce sautéed with prosciutto, onions and basil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95
    19.95

    Gnocchi Bolognese

    19.95
    Meat sauce topped with ricotta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 17.50
    17.50

    Spaghetti & Meatballs

    17.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.95
    20.95

    Chicken & Broccoli

    20.95
    Chicken, broccoli, garlic, oil, fresh tomato and rigatoni pasta
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 19.95
    19.95

    Capellini Primavera

    19.95
    Asparagus, shiitake mushrooms, sundried tomato, fresh zucchini, fresh garlic and oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.95
    20.95

    Linguini with Clam Sauce

    20.95
    Red or white
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.95
    20.95

    Rigatoni Rustica

    20.95
    Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, garlic & oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.95
    23.95

    Shrimp Cappellini

    23.95
    Arugula, tomatoes, roasted garlic, white wine
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Ravioli

    14.95
    Cheese ravioli with tomato sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.50
    16.50

    Baked Ravioli

    16.50
    Cheese ravioli with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95 - 15.95
    14.95 - 15.95

    Baked Ziti

    14.95 - 15.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 16.95
    16.95

    Lasagna with Meat

    16.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 18.95
    18.95

    Fettuccine Alfredo

    18.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Parmigiana

  • 11.50 - 20.95
    11.50 - 20.95

    Chicken

    11.50 - 20.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50 - 20.95
    11.50 - 20.95

    Meatball

    11.50 - 20.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.50 - 19.95
    10.50 - 19.95

    Eggplant

    10.50 - 19.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50 - 20.95
    11.50 - 20.95

    Grilled Chicken

    11.50 - 20.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 11.50 - 20.95
    11.50 - 20.95

    Sausage & Peppers

    11.50 - 20.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.50 - 22.95
    13.50 - 22.95

    Shrimp

    13.50 - 22.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Main Plates

  • 26.95
    26.95

    Coal Fired Organic Chicken

    26.95
    sweet potatoes and summer vegetables
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 29.95
    29.95

    Seafood Marinara

    29.95
    Shrimp, clams, mussels, calamari over linguine
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 20.95
    20.95

    Eggplant Rollatini

    20.95
    Ricotta, marinara, melted mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 24.95
    24.95

    Chicken Rollatini

    24.95
    stuffed w/ prosciutto, mozzarella, marsala wine sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.95
    23.95

    Chicken Milanese

    23.95
    arugula, cherry tomatoes, artichokes, olives, lemon, olive oil
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.95
    23.95

    Chicken Francese

    23.95
    Lemon, butter, white wine sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.95
    23.95

    Chicken Marsala

    23.95
    Fresh mushrooms, brown marsala sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.95
    23.95

    Chicken Scarpariello

    23.95
    Sweet sausage, potatoes, cherry peppers, mushrooms
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 24.95
    24.95

    Chicken Sorrentino

    24.95
    Eggplant, prosciutto, mushroom, melted mozzarella
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 23.95
    23.95

    Chicken Bruschetta

    23.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Sides

  • 11.50
    11.50

    Broccoli Rabe

    11.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.95
    9.95

    Escarole & Beans

    9.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.50
    8.50

    Broccoli

    8.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Spinach

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.95
    8.95

    Meatballs (3)

    8.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 5.95
    5.95

    Side of French Fries

    5.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Kids Menu

  • 9.50
    9.50

    Chicken Fingers & Fries

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Mozzarella Sticks

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Mac & Cheese

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Grilled Cheese & Fries

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Penne Vodka

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Florets

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Kids Pasta Bowl

    9.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    (1) Meatball

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Desserts

  • 8.50
    8.50

    Brownie Sundae

    8.50
    Ghirardelli chocolate brownie served with vanilla bean ice cream and whipped cream
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.95
    10.95

    Brownie Fritters

    10.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 10.95
    10.95

    Fried Oreo

    10.95
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.50
    8.50

    Cookie Dough Blast

    8.50
    Warm chocolate chip cookie with chocolate filling served with vanilla bean ice cream
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 8.50
    8.50

    Funnel Sticks

    8.50
    Sweet fried dough dusted with confectioners' sugar served with caramel dipping sauce
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 9.50
    9.50

    Tartufo

    9.50
    Vanilla and chocolate ice cream with raspberry and nut center dipped ia a dark chocolate shell
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 13.95
    13.95

    Sweetie Pie Sundae

    13.95
    Warm sweet dough topped with vanilla bean ice cream, caramel, chocolate syrup and whipped cream ( serves 2 or more)
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 14.95
    14.95

    Nutella S'mores Pie

    14.95
    Warm sweet dough topped with roasted marshmallow, banana and graham crackers (serves 2 or more )
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Beverages

  • 4.00
    4.00

    2 Liter Coke

    4.00
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.00
    4.00

    2 Liter Diet Coke

    4.00
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 4.00
    4.00

    2 Liter Sprite

    4.00
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 3.99
    3.99

    Boylan Black Cherry

    3.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 3.99
    3.99

    Boylan Creme

    3.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 3.99
    3.99

    Boylan Orange

    3.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 3.99
    3.99

    Boylan Ginger Ale

    3.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 3.99
    3.99

    Boylan Root Beer

    3.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.50
    2.50

    20oz Coke

    2.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.50
    2.50

    20oz Diet Coke

    2.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.50
    2.50

    20oz Sprite

    2.50
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Fountain Drink - Coke

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Fountain Drink - Diet Coke

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Fountain Drink - Sprite

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Fountain Drink - Dr. Pepper

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Fountain Drink - Root Beer

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Iced Tea

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Hi - C

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 2.99
    2.99

    Lemonade

    2.99
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Catering Package

  • 168.00
    168.00

    Package #1

    168.00
    Feeds 8-10 People

    ·House Salad
    ·Penne alla Vodka or Baked Ziti
    ·Chicken Francaise, Marsala, or
    ·Parmigiana
    ·Garlic Knots

    *All items are half trays
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 279.00
    279.00

    Package #2

    279.00
    Feeds 15-20 People

    ·House Salad
    ·Penne alla Vodka or Baked Ziti
    ·Eggplant Parmigiana or Rollatini
    ·Sausage and Peppers or Meatballs
    ·Chicken Francaise, Marsala or Parmigiana
    ·Garlic Knots

    *All items are half trays
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 405.00
    405.00

    Package #3

    405.00
    Feeds 25-30 People

    ·House Salad
    ·Penne alla Vodka or Baked Ziti
    ·Eggplant Parmigiana or Rollatini
    ·Chicken Francaise, Marsala or Parmigiana
    ·Garlic Knots

    **All items are full trays
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 685.00
    685.00

    Package #4

    685.00
    Feeds 50-60 People

    ·House Salad
    ·Penne alla Vodka
    ·Eggplant Parmigiana or Rollatini
    ·Chicken Francaise, Marsala, or
    ·Parmigiana
    ·Baked Ziti
    ·Rigatoni Rustica
    ·Large Grilled Vegetable Platter
    ·Garlic Knots

    **All items are full trays
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity
  • 925.00
    925.00

    Package #5

    925.00
    Feeds 70-80 People

    ·House Salad
    ·Shrimp Scampi over Linguine
    ·Penne alla Vodka
    ·Eggplant Parmigiana or Rollatini
    ·Chicken Francaise, Marsala, or
    ·Parmigiana
    ·Baked Ziti
    ·Sausage and Peppers
    ·Meatballs
    ·Large Grilled Vegetable Platter
    ·Garlic Knots

    **All items are full trays
    Add Special Instructions
    Quantity

Dynamic Category

      Your Order

      This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.

      Your order is empty.

      {{combo.name}} Delete Combo {{comboPrice(combo)}}

      Already Sent

      Subtotal

      Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
      {{submitButtonText}}

      Info

      No-Contact Delivery Min: $20.00
      Already Registered? Sign In
      Online Ordering Powered by:
      Orders2me Online Ordering System for Restaurants
      Terms of Service & Privacy Policy
      {{submitButtonText}}

      Start Your Order

      Sorry, we're closed right now. When do you want to order?

      Choose Order Type

      Order Time
      In-store Pickup orders are not available right now.
      We deliver, but delivery is not available right now.

      Already Registered?

      Invalid username or password.
      Forgot password?

      Sign In

      Invalid username or password.
      Forgot password?

      Forgot Your Password?

      Please enter your e-mail address, and we'll send you a link to reset your password.

      Please check your e-mail

      Item Added

      Your selection has been added to your order.
      Make Your Order Even Better!

      Item Added

      Your selection has been added to your order.
      Continue Ordering

      Have a Coupon?

      If you have a coupon code, enter it and click Apply Coupon.

      Complete Your Order

      Complete Your Coupon

      You've earned a free item! Select the item you want below.

      Info

      Your Order

      This restaurant is not currently accepting orders.

      Your order is empty.

      {{combo.name}} Delete Combo {{comboPrice(combo)}}

      Already Sent

      Subtotal

      Coupon: {{coupon.name}}
      {{submitButtonText}}

      We're On It!

      Your items have been sent and we're working on it! Want to order more? Go for it!